Donald Trump’s recent federal takeover of Washington D. C. has brought attention to urban blight and crime, especially in Democrat-run cities. In a detailed article, “Our Insane Mental Health System,” Mary Grabar, Resident Fellow, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI), analyzes the epidemic of disorder on city streets, linking it to government decisions made decades ago that decommitted mentally ill people from confinement.

Most of the people ranting to nobody within earshot and otherwise behaving strangely cannot really be stopped just by enforcing loitering laws. Many need to be institutionalized, according to Barry Latzer, a major crime expert at the City University of New York, whom Dr. Grabar quotes in her article in the August 5th issue of Gloria Greenfield’s Doc Emet Productions.

Dr. Grabar describes the crucial background of de-institutionalization. According to E. Fuller Torrey, who specializes in mental illness, state-run asylums “were shut down after the Kennedy Administration began granting federal funds to community centers.” At about same time, “a shift in attitudes toward the mentally ill” occurred. The popular movie One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest enshrined a narrative of rampant abuses at state psychiatric hospitals.

Financial misconduct bedeviled community centers from the start and were mostly used, Dr. Grabar writes, “by those facing challenges like divorce or low-level depression … not the severely mentally ill.”  People who “suffer from anosognosia—a condition that prevents individuals from recognizing their own illness … are unaware of their mental illness; they need supervision to ensure that they take their medication.”  Ever since the 1980s, citizens have witnessed “the addicted and psychotic” meandering the city streets. The untreated commit horrible crimes. “One never knows if the ranting man will … push you onto the train tracks.”

Another serious problem is the unrealistically high threshold required for institutionalization: “There are family members desperate to help who have been held back by a legal system that maintains the ‘imminent danger’ criteria for involuntary commitment.”  One mother’s account describes the problem in most states. “Her son who suffers from schizophrenia was not able to get help and was incarcerated. On four occasions, she begged professionals and emergency services to hospitalize him but was told that he was ‘not dangerous enough.’” In short, the health professionals and advocates for the mentally ill dangerously drowned out the family members who lobbied for institutionalization.

Detailing a variety of horrific incidents and some proposed state-level legislation, Dr. Grabar also notes President Trump’s executive order of July 24, “Ending Crime and Disorder on America’s Streets.” Prompted by the tent cities in Washington, D.C., it “aims to take the homeless, of which two-thirds are mentally ill or drug-addicted, off the streets and into treatment programs.” The U.S. Justice Department will roll back regulations that keep states and businesses from removing homeless people from the streets and will use federal funding to incentivize officials to enforce prohibitions on open drug use, urban camping and loitering, and urban squatting.

Dr. Grabar comments: “This is a step in the right direction, even if the effort is limited to the homeless. But critical questions need to be addressed,” especially about what will happen on the state level.

In addition to her frequent commentaries, Dr. Grabar is the author of three books: Debunking FDR: The Man and the Myths (2025), Debunking the 1619 Project: Exposing the Plan to Divide America (2021), and Debunking Howard Zinn: Exposing the Fake History That Turned a Generation against America (2019).