Dean Ball, member of the board of directors, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI), continues providing thoughtful analyses of artificial intelligence. Mr. Ball recently offered readers of his successful online newsletter Hyperdimensional an introduction to the AI child safety issue.
Child safety is now an especially active area in AI policymaking. Dozens of such laws were introduced in state legislatures last year alone—and understandably so, Mr. Ball acknowledges. AI is a cognitive tool, “and children’s minds are more vulnerable than the minds of adults.”
In his recently published essay “On AI and Children,” Mr. Ball sees both “good and bad ways to write AI child safety laws.” In his judgment, government should pass laws “to require large AI companies to enable age verification or detection, impose content guardrails for minors, and offer parental controls.” But policymakers must think about a crucial difference between artificial intelligence and social media:
The “range of possible relationships—including ones where the human draws emotional support from the AI—is extremely broad. The best language models today offer me advice on some of the weightiest personal and professional questions I must grapple with. I consider them some of the best thought partners I have … and I say this as someone who has … a rich and diverse social life. . . . If a child is clearly struggling with homework, or with an interpersonal problem in school, it is fine, probably even healthy, for them to talk it out with a language model.”
Potentially riskier, however, are AI-generated friendships. The best examples of genuine AI-related tragedies involve “children interacting with pure companion AIs from firms like Character.AI or with generalist AIs like ChatGPT.” Some have resulted in lawsuits—and the bad publicity, expense, and complexity involved in litigation, plus the potentially immense cost of a settlement or jury award, create a powerful incentive to prevent such tragedies.
Currently, under the threat of lawsuits, OpenAI has offered to “undertake age detection, parental controls, and content guardrails for minors, precisely the policy outcomes I think would be most appropriate.” Most well advised firms will want to do the same to take “preemptive action.”
What about AI “chatbots,” with which people including children can have something like a human relationship? Regulating these effectively may meet with significant frustrations. We can be sure that “no regulation of … child safety—or really any other regulation of an AI model or system—will be universally observed … noncompliant AI will proliferate, and the existence of the law will be the cause of that proliferation.”
For example: “If millions of parents dislike their children using AI for … homework, and use their … mandatory parental controls … there will be a demand … for access to AI their parents cannot monitor so easily. [Such models] might not be at the frontier of intelligence, but most … are more than smart enough to write a B+ middle or high school essay at an average American public school.”
Mr. Ball calls special attention, though, to a newer aspect of artificial intelligence: coding agents. “Coding agents of the near future might well be able to scrape hours of pornography from the internet, discover vulnerabilities in school networks to access … documents (like answer keys or grades), hack into the smart home equipment of the girl a fifteen-year-old boy has a crush on.”
Mr. Ball sums his article on child safety as follows: “Is there some broader education we might wish to impart on a child before we let him use technologies with such power? … some societal sense of individual responsibility in the use of AI we should be attempting to develop and instill?” That “strikes me as a more promising direction for a genuinely pro-child safety, pro-family, and pro-social policy on artificial intelligence.”
In addition to his Hyperdimensional newsletter on Substack, Mr. Ball’s AI background includes service last year with the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy helping to develop the Trump administration’s AI development strategy, and a position with the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. Currently a senior fellow at the Foundation for American Innovation, he is a 2014 graduate of Hamilton College and former AHI Undergraduate Fellow.
Leave A Comment