Juliana Pilon, Senior Fellow, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI), scolds Anne Applebaum, a well-known international affairs journalist and author, for misleading partisanship. In Applebaum’s new book Autocracy, Inc.: The Dictators Who Want to Run the World on centralized rule and its influence upon the West, Dr. Pilon observes, “National security requires at least a modicum of strategic clarity and bipartisanship.” Applebaum “attempts it … but fails.”

In the years after the fall of Soviet-bloc communism, Applebaum writes, Russia became “a mafia state built and managed entirely for the purpose of enriching its leaders.” In this sordid process, Western collaboration became “essential.” In her view, such cooperation has continued and now endangers the West.

In “Axis of Deception” in the November 15 issue of Law & Liberty, an online publication of Liberty Fund, Dr. Pilon acknowledges that there are economic dangers in Western economies’ connection to autocratic countries and regimes. The often intimate relationships Applebaum sees between autocratic governments and CEOs of major international corporations are especially worrisome given “the democratic world’s dependence on China, Russia, and other autocracies for minerals, semiconductors, or energy supplies.” Chinese businesses are particularly notorious for stealing information that their regime might use to wage cyberwarfare.

Unfortunately, Applebaum’s purpose is “unabashedly partisan” on behalf of the Democrats, and this bias distorts her book. “[M]odern autocrats—specifically from Russia and China—spend lavishly ‘on television outlets, local and national newspapers, [and] troll networks.” Applebaum praises the State Department Global Engagement Center (GEC) for its “efforts to combat disinformation.” But she utters “[n]ot a word about the Congressional report documenting GEC’s violating its mission by itself engaging in partisan censorship.”

According to Dr. Pilon, Applebaum misses our failure to regulate our own social media, which does far more than our foreign adversaries to mislead us: “If any business sector should be singled out as cynically disseminating selective information that endangers not only Israel but America and its allies, it is the mainstream media.”

Dr. Pilon, who holds a Ph.D. in philosophy from the University of Chicago, is most recently the author of The Utopian Conceit and the War on Freedom (2019) and The Art of Peace: Engaging a Complex World (2016). Over the years, she has published more than two hundred articles and reviews on international affairs, human rights, literature, and philosophy, with frequent radio and television appearances. Dr. Pilon has taught at numerous colleges and universities including the National Defense University, Emory, Johns Hopkins, and the Rochester Institute of Technology. From 2010 to 2013, she directed the Center for Culture and Security at the Institute of World Politics in Washington.