A new U.S. annual report that studies America’s relations with China has recommended that “Congress establish and fund a Manhattan Project-like program” so that the nation would have the means of “racing to and acquiring an Artificial General Intelligence.” Dean Ball, board member, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI), proves skeptical of that proposal.

In “Questions, Unasked and Unanswered” in the November 20th issue of his online newsletter Hyperdimensional, Mr. Ball begins by noting that it might simply be “a trial balloon” intended to measure the public’s reaction to such a development.   In such a scenario, the U.S. government “would be first in line” for artificial intelligence models as they are produced, for AI-related services as they develop, and for electrical and all other infrastructure that the actual use of AI will require. Mr. Ball estimates that it would take hundreds of billions of dollars to realize such a venture.

“You would think, with such a detailed report from such a well-regarded … group, there would be a great deal of explanation for a proposal of this magnitude … But you would be wrong.” Indeed, not even a justification for this extreme recommendation is provided.

Mr. Ball, a former AHI undergraduate fellow and a current research fellow specializing in AI at George Mason University’s Mercatus Center, has many exacting questions about this heady Manhattan Project for artificial intelligence. Among them, “Who will lead this initiative?”

“Yet in a nearly 800-page report, precisely none of these questions are asked, and precisely none are answered.”