Leftists’ faint or disingenuous professions of sadness at the assassination of Charlie Kirk stand as moral bankruptcy when they suggest even a slight justification for it. They place themselves outside the realm of respectable citizenship and, indeed, humanity. Alexander Riley, Senior Fellow, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI), has written an eloquent analysis of Kirk’s assassination for the September 18th issue of Chronicles: A Magazine of American Culture entitled “The ‘Sad Charlie Kirk Died, But …’ Crowd Is Not Worth Your Time.”

In a nutshell, Charlie Kirk was assassinated for debating political ideas. His murder, Dr. Riley observes, “should call forth in every American … the same powerful moral clarity that his loss as a father and husband does. Any American … who cannot mourn the murder of a man killed for doing something so basic to the American identity will never be swayed by reason or facts, and discourse with such men is fruitless.”

There is no room for shades of gray here! “You are either against such horrific acts, or you are not.” A ‘but’ implies wiggle room for the morally justifiable. “It also indicates that you are an opponent of the effort to save this culture from going off the moral cliff.”

Dr. Riley, a senior professor of sociology at Bucknell University, finds the conjunction “but” to describe the assassination of Kirk to be additional evidence—if such was needed— of the radical left’s absolute hostility toward dissent from the opinions it most passionately holds. Most elites “made up their minds about Charlie Kirk without listening to or reading his words. . .. They reveal in the hysterical, totalitarian intolerance of their view just how little they see as utterable on the topics they consider sacred.”

Americans who think and feel this way “will never succeed in their nightmarish desire of getting everyone to believe precisely what they do, but they will settle for nothing less,” Dr. Riley adds and, therefore, these people will eventually destroy civil society. Of this, there is not the slightest doubt.”

He also sees the extreme danger of years of failure by authorities to do their work to crack down on the brutal Antifa movement and in the public’s failure to demand it: “A central part of the Antifa message has always been about ‘eliminating fascists.’ A society that tolerates Antifa—and similar types—will get what is coming to it. And a society that tolerates an intellectual class that will encourage the antifa thugs and murderers will, too.”

Dr. Riley’s books include Angel Patriots: The Crash of United Flight 93 and the Myth of America (2015), and Toward a Biosocial Science: Evolutionary Theory, Human Nature, and Social Life (2021).