This month marks the 100th anniversary of the birth of the legendary conservative advocate William F. Buckley Jr., founder and editor of National Review. And this year has seen the very long-awaited publication of a massive biography of Buckley by former New York Times Book Review editor Sam Tanenhaus.

Many reviews, often critical, have been published in major outlets. David Frisk, Resident Fellow, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI), has added his name to the list. As the author of the only biography of Buckley’s close colleague of three decades, William Rusher, Dr. Frisk has especially strong qualifications for evaluating Buckley: The Life and the Revolution That Changed America.

Dr. Frisk’s review appeared this month in Modern Age, one of the most prestigious, time-honored conservative publications. Russell Kirk, another conservative icon, started the journal in 1957, just two years after Buckley started National Review.

In “The Last Word on William F. Buckley Jr.?,” Dr. Frisk praises Tanenhaus’s biography for its strong, respectful understanding of Buckley as a human being. Tanenhaus performs impressive research into his life, especially his upbringing and early career. But he emphasizes that his book does not analyze Buckley’s political and intellectual influence in any depth: “The reader … will know Buckley well … but … the man, not the public figure.” The biography provides “little analysis of what … Buckley said and wrote to mass audiences about the great issues of the age, or of his judgments about how the growing, anxious, underdog conservative movement, much of which looked to him for inspiration and wisdom, should proceed.”

Under his leadership, William F. Buckley took National Review from scratch to dazzling heights. Yet, Dr. Frisk laments that we fail to “learn much about Buckley’s captaincy of NR, his greatest tangible contribution to our public life.” Buckley brought into existence “a bold yet thoughtful, artfully poised, often funny, not wholly predictable opinion journal.” Tanenhaus’s narrative misses the mark in that crucial facets of Buckley’s career remain in the background, playing a subordinate role “to something like investigative journalism.”

Tanenhaus’s investigation of Buckley teems with industriously gleaned minutiae. They lend a revealing flavor in strict biographical terms. But they also tend to shortchange the public life of a truly remarkable man. “[T]he stress here … ends up shrinking him to … less than a history-making leader or prophet, less than the leader of a ‘revolution’ that changed America. Close, perhaps, but not quite.”

But Dr. Frisk gives full credit to the book’s commendable warmth and its thoughtful personal evaluations: “A friendly fascination with Buckley and respect for his great talents, for his kindness to nearly all … balances Tanenhaus’s negative judgments. Those judgments—that Buckley was far from scholarly or truly philosophical, for example—are the ones conservatives should be well aware of and be willing to accept if they find them substantiated. It is also worth knowing in detail what a centrally situated nonconservative intellectual such as Tanenhaus … finds most impressive and praiseworthy as well as most flawed in him.”

In addition, Dr. Frisk recently reviewed a shorter book focused on Buckley’s love of classical music and his devotion to mentoring: American Impresario: William F. Buckley, Jr., and the Elements of American Character by Lawrence Perelman. The review was published by Liberty Fund’s prominent website for books and essays, Law & Liberty.

Dr. Frisk is the author of the widely acclaimed biography If Not Us, Who? William Rusher, National Review, and the Conservative Movement (ISI Books, 2012) and holds a Ph.D. in political science from Claremont Graduate University. He teaches the AHI’s popular continuing education courses in history, political science, and political thought.