Federal Judge Michael F. Urbanski, a Barack Obama appointee, has rendered a decision in a case that centered on speech rights after a renaming controversy in Virginia. Judge Urbanski sided with the NAACP after a school board sought to rename the school back to Stonewall Jackson High School, whose nickname was the “Generals.”

Judge Urbanski determined in his initial decision that the renaming was “a symbol of racial exclusion.” A trial awaits for the remaining issues.

In the September 20 issue of The College Fix, Mary Grabar, Resident Fellow, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI), responds to Judge Urbanski’s verdict. “‘I do not think that returning the school name to its original name violates the speech rights of students . . .. Schools and other public institutions are often named after people that some members of the public do not like.’”

The NAACP looked to General Ty Seidule, a Hamilton College faculty member, as an expert on the Civil War. Dr. Grabar had previously lambasted Seidule, a George Soros-funded progressive, for serving as director of Hamilton College’s misnamed ‘Common Ground’ series.

Dr. Grabar also discussed about the potential for parents to challenge schools throughout the country named after Barack Obama. “‘Certainly, a student wanting to enroll in one of the many schools named after Barack Obama (many of them early in his presidency before his legacy could be established) would face the same constraints of referring to his school and his sports team to an individual that his parents did not support or vote for,’ Grabar said. ‘Of course, if someone were to file a lawsuit there would be an uproar.’”

Her key message is to grow up. “‘There are plenty of places ‘named after individuals that many do not like’ and ‘part of being a citizen’ is living with these ‘realities and compromises.’”  Part of maturation begins with respectfully disagreeing with someone else. “‘It would be good character-building for adulthood.’”