Vice President J.D. Vance spoke on artificial intelligence at the recent AI Action Summit in Paris. Dean Ball, member of the board of directors of The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI), observes that his “admirable” comments proved skeptical about the wisdom of a vast regulatory scheme for the industry. Despite Vance’s warning, Mr. Ball, a specialist on the rapidly developing AI revolution, warns that the United States is highly unlikely to avoid this damaging outcome.
In “The EU AI Act is Coming to America” for the February 13 issue of Mr. Ball’s successful newsletter Hyperdimensional, he maintains that Vance rightly “chastised the European Union for moving too quickly with preemptive regulations” of AI. While indicating “that the Trump Administration would not be following in the EU’s lead,” however, many states are moving toward stifling laws.
The envisioned laws aim to regulate AI-automated decision making in ways intended to prevent unfair “algorithmic discrimination” in “high-risk” uses. They would impose “preemptive paperwork and risk management requirements” when AI is what they call a “substantial factor” in making a “consequential decision.” That’s any decision, Mr. Ball explains, affecting “a consumer’s access to, terms of, or price of services” in employment, education, legal services, finance, insurance, utilities, government services, and in some cases much more.
For every such AI use, any covered business would have to “write and implement a risk management plan and create an algorithmic impact assessment.” Small businesses would be exempted in some states, but in others “the law would apply to everyone—including individual users … in a personal capacity. All parties—developer and deployer—also face the possibility of negligence liability.” Mr. Ball spells out the practical significance of that effort.
So far only Colorado, last May, has passed such a bill. Efforts to simplify the overly complex law before it takes effect in 2026 are, by all accounts, a muddle. “After nearly a year of meetings, Colorado does not know” how to implement it. Nonetheless, states are piling on the bandwagon. Similar measures are being considered in California, New York, Texas, and nine other states—with more perhaps in the offing.
And how necessary are they? Is there evidence that algorithmic discrimination is such a significant problem that it’s worth paying the likely costs? “I believe the answer is no … I believe the compliance costs … [would outweigh] the modest benefits the laws might deliver.” In addition, there are “many other ways these laws could harm … innovation and technology diffusion, creating a weaker American AI ecosystem overall.”
Mr. Ball, a former AHI undergraduate fellow, serves currently as a fellow of George Mason University’s Mercatus Center.
Leave A Comment