The renewed obsession with economic inequality and the increasing friendliness toward socialism among many “progressives” has attracted the attention of Alexander Riley, Senior Fellow, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI). In the November issue of Chronicles: A Magazine of American Culture, Dr. Riley reviews a short new book Equality: What It Means and Why It Matters by the prominent French economist Thomas Piketty and Harvard political theorist Michael Sandel.
In “Some Are More Equal than Others,” Dr. Riley vigorously challenges the dogmatism and extreme policy positions of the book. Inequality is “a universal feature of human societies,” he notes in his assessment. The evidence for this “is overwhelming. No society without inequality has ever existed … it is difficult even to imagine what a society with no inequality would look like.”
The authors fail to discuss “why and in what forms inequality is a bad or avoidable thing. The book simply posits ‘democracy’ and ‘equality’ as … sacred idols.” In addition, they fail to delve into a thornier question of how human freedom conflicts with equality. In what ways is equality incompatible with freedom? Should we not consider inequality as a hallmark of civilization?
Few adults can doubt that the educational system in the United States today remains corrupted by ideology. Dr. Riley, a senior professor of sociology at Bucknell University, gives higher education particularly failing marks for blindly accepting first principles, for unexamined premises. “Perhaps most…will agree with the unargued principle that equality is inherently good—perhaps those are the only readers Piketty and Sandel care to reach.” A serious book, however, cannot presume to posit that “equality” stands as an unmixed good. Freedom and equality live in tension with each other.
Sandel cites Jean-Jacques Rousseau that private property is the root of all evil. Piketty chimes in that “inequality in property and disparities in talent are nothing more than problems to be overcome.” The damning experiments carried out in the name of social justice are the results of this kind of thinking. The authors stubbornly urge socialism despite what are clearly huge difficulties even in systems not quite as ambitious, namely today’s welfare states.
In short, Piketty and Sandel press their views as a type of utopian egalitarianism without facing the hard consequences of their actions in real time. Social democracies, they write, must be transformed into “‘participatory and democratic socialist’ states.” Piketty, on his part, advocates, for a “‘federal internationalist socialism’ …a ‘United States of the World with progressive taxation.’” Dr. Riley counters: there is “no upper bracket tax rate high enough to pay for all the welfare programs that Piketty and Sandel desire.”
Dr. Riley also disputes their agenda for higher education. “Equality [in their view] will require more than the systematic expropriation of the wealthy. We will also need more people in college, though the evidence is vast that this is unsustainable.” Piketty and Sandel have come out against legacy admissions. In fact, states Dr. Riley, “legacy students have higher test scores on average and typically have other characteristics that make them more qualified than the average student.”
Unsurprisingly, their egalitarian extremism in regard to higher education goes far indeed. “In Sandel’s vision, schools would place all applicants who met minimal requirements into a hat and pick them at random. This, he believes, would eliminate the advantages … to candidates from wealthier families.” Piketty desires breathtaking social engineering: “half of all acceptances” would derive from “the lower two-thirds of the socioeconomic ladder.”
And would the authors be willing to practice what they preach? “Sandel has two sons; Piketty has three daughters. It would be interesting to know what work they have done to help their own children advance, and whether any … have attended elite schools. Public figures who are zealous egalitarians should make such information known, as it is essential for evaluating their intellectual seriousness. If they … do not take their egalitarianism seriously, then why should we?”
A member of the National Association of Scholars board, Dr. Riley is the author of Angel Patriots: The Crash of United Flight 93 and the Myth of America (2015) and Toward a Biosocial Science: Evolutionary Theory, Human Nature, and Social Life (2021).
Leave A Comment