Is it possible China will win the artificial intelligence race in at least one important way, outcompeting the United States in the development of widespread consumer uses? The answer may be “yes,” says Dean Ball, member of the board, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI) and research fellow with the Mercatus Center at George Mason University.
In “Why Manus Matters” at Mr. Ball’s online newsletter Hyperdimensional, he recently tried out Manus, which was announced by a Chinese AI startup company as “the first general AI agent.” The artificial intelligence system can perform multiple tasks on a computer like booking a train trip, just as a human might. He was impressed.
Major companies such as OpenAI and Anthropic, and even other startups, have already developed “general agents” of this kind. After sampling the new system, however, Mr. Ball’s “tentative conclusion from that experience—as well as the uses I have seen from others—is that Manus is the best general-purpose computer use agent I have ever tried,” despite its “glitchiness, unpredictability, and other problems.”
Why did “an unheard-of Chinese startup” do it first? “There is no magic here, no deep technical insight or feat—at least not one I can see,” Mr. Ball notes. “Manus took existing approaches to agent development … and shipped a product with a well-executed marketing campaign. Many in the AI community seem to turn their noses up at such things, but I struggle to understand why.”
Manus is an example of the integration of AI into other products and services, known as “diffusion”—and its advent lends further credence to the possibility of “an emerging Chinese edge” in the diffusion of artificial intelligence.
In the 19th century, Europe was the great scientific innovator—but “did not use their innovations to their maximum advantage; instead, that honor went to America—the hungry, less sophisticated upstart. Europe led in innovation, but America led in diffusion … America thus reaped just as many, if not more, of the economic benefits of new inventions.”
In our time, “Manus is evidence that something similar could happen in AI.” Mr. Ball discusses several reasons why America might become a laggard in AI “diffusion.” An important one, he stresses, may be the looming shadow of heavy governmental regulation of AI in the United States—covered in previous Hyperdimensional essays.
He ends with these questions: “Why is the AI transformation thus far so colorless compared to previous technology transitions? Where is the joy, the Steve Jobsian creativity? Have we somehow squashed it?”
Leave A Comment