Volodymyr Zelensky, the President of Ukraine, clashed with Donald Trump, President of the United States, prior to a rare earth deal to the benefit of both countries. The deal (temporarily?) fell through. President Trump disinvited Zelensky from the Oval Office and paused military aid to the eastern European country.

Neoconservative Bret Stephens and liberal Maureen Dowd, columnists for The New York Times, responded to the dust-up. They published scathing pieces about President Trump’s behavior during the meeting by referencing the “sainted” Franklin Delano Roosevelt. Mary Grabar, Resident Fellow, The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization (AHI), responded with a history lesson of her own.

In “Trump Is No FDR … and Zelensky Is No Churchill” for the March 5 issue of Chronicles:  A Magazine of American Culture, Dr. Grabar takes issue with Stephens’ and Dowd’s rendering of the meeting. Browbeaten by Trump and Vice President J. D. Vance, noted Stephens, Zelensky was “lecture[d] on manners from the most mendacious vulgarian and ungracious host ever to inhabit the White House.” For her part, Dowd called Trump’s meeting with Zelensky a “sickening spectacle: the man who tried to upend democracy bullying the man who is fighting for democracy.”

In truth, Dr. Grabar writes, ‘[w]hen it came time for real negotiations, FDR’s ineptness and infatuation with [Joseph] Stalin ensured it was Soviet Russia that ‘aggrandized’ territory—including Ukraine.” Dowd stated, “Can you imagine F.D.R. petulantly ordering Churchill to be more thankful?” Well, yes, observes Dr. Grabar. Roosevelt “repeatedly bullied and humiliated Churchill for Stalin’s benefit.”

Grabar concludes that the meeting between Zelensky and Trump on February 28 will go down as memorable history. “But don’t trust the Democrat version.”

Mary Grabar’s book Debunking FDR: The Man and the Myths will be published on March 11th.